Review: Cracking performance combining superb script, acting and direction


We’ve all said it. You meet someone on holiday, exchange contact details and “…if you are ever in Warwickshire…”.
Curmudgeon Peter [Mark Plastow] and his polite socially adept wife Debbie [Esther Riggs] were on a cruise, cleverly and simply conjured by three deckchairs. The third chair was occupied by loud, brash Elsa [Julia-Ann Rendell], who said if they were ever in Denver…, which they had no intention of doing. Yet she cunningly turned the tables when four months later she turned up at their house in London.
The Unfriend
Performed at The Talisman Theatre, Monday 09 February [until 14 February 2026].


Directed by: Vanessa Comer
Mark and Esther wonderfully evoked their family dynamics as they discussed how to put off Elsa’s impending visit. Mark portrayed Peter’s shambling, unassertive and rather weak character while Esther depicted Debbie becoming increasingly fraught, especially when she Googled Elsa. Director Vanessa Comer cleverly used screens to the side of the stage to give some background including news reports from the USA, which moved the plot along quickly to herald Elsa’s arrival. This allowed the play to focus on the real crux: What to do once she was in their house? The whole plot revolved around British politeness and the unwanted situations this can lead to.
Adam Turner gave an assured performance as teenage son Alex, obsessed with on-line gaming, and Alais McKluskey was truly believable as the self-obsessed petulant teen daughter.Their roles gave authenticity to the family as the parents struggled with how not to cause offence by asking Elsa to leave. A very clever short scene tackled an imaginary “what-if?”.
This was a terrific script with numerous laugh-out loud moments with sharp witty dialogue. All the characters were believable and the comic timing of the actors was first-rate. The very experienced Julia-Ann Rendell was outstanding with her energy, not flagging for a moment in this demanding role, and maintaining her American accent throughout. Mark also had a very big part and was word perfect with mannerisms ranging from confusion to bemusement to frustration, as he and Esther portrayed a typical middle class Guardian-reading couple.


Phil Reynolds gave an excellent understated performance as the busybody meddlesome nameless neighbour. His characterisation was ideal and the passive-aggressive comments on Peter and Debbie’s lifestyle were delivered faultlessly. Mark Oram had a lovely cameo role as the policeman, initially with food poisoning, which led to an hilarious toilet scene, and then also taken in by Elsa’s charms.
This was a reviewer’s delight when script, plot, direction and acting come together for a cracking performance. The full house got real value for money and this was an antidote that will have lifted the potential gloom of weather and the state of the world.