All major advances have their problems

Reading R P Taylor’s letter last week comparing a modern transport system to a century-old plan for the invasion of France, I feel compelled to ask what else reminds him of the Schlieffen Plan on the basis that “the details [have] been considered” and “every modern device [has] been employed.” Brain surgery? The internet? Mobile phones?

If Mr Taylor were to read a little more history, he might equate HS to other groundbreaking transportation initiatives - the building of the first railways in the 1830s, the expansion of the motorway network in the 50s and 60s, or the boom in passenger air travel in the last 50 years. All major advances, none without their own peculiar problems, but each contributing significantly to the country’s modernity and prosperity. - Alasdair Russell, via email.

Related topics: