Stratford District Council: Panel chair quits having worked with “one hand tied behind back”

The long-serving chair of a panel that oversees Stratford-on-Avon District Council’s work has stood down alleging it was like working with “one hand tied behind your back”.

Councillor Andy Crump (Con, Southam East, Central & Stockton) has led the district’s overview and scrutiny committee for four years – the final year of it being a Conservative-run council and the past three years under Liberal Democrat rule.

He previously worked as a council officer in another authority and was Warwickshire County Council’s portfolio holder for fire and rescue and community safety until the Tories lost power at Shire Hall in 2025, chairing scrutiny of that service at county level since then.

Scrutiny panels at all authorities are meant to cut through political fervour with questions and recommendations on policies and how they are implemented – their membership is dictated by the political balance of the council it represents.

Councillor Andy Crump. Credit: Warwickshire County Council.placeholder image
Councillor Andy Crump. Credit: Warwickshire County Council.

Cllr Crump last week resigned as chair of Stratford’s committee, stating in his letter that he had been “considering this action for a little while”.

He made reference to a comment from council leader Councillor Susan Juned (Lib Dem, Alcester East) in a recent cabinet meeting that meetings should not last more than two hours, citing examples of planning committees and full council meetings going well beyond that point.

He added that the most recent scrutiny meeting saw Warwickshire’s Police and Crime Commissioner Philip Seccombe (Con) attend alongside police officers and that more than 40 pre-meeting questions had been submitted, leading to that section alone taking an hour-and-a-half.

Cllr Crump also raised concern about a lack of engagement from some panel members.

He told the Local Democracy Reporting Service: “There were times where I had to ask probing questions because it appeared to me that others had either not read the papers or had not prepared properly. Some residents have told me they thought exactly the same.

“You are almost doing scrutiny with one hand tied behind your back. The preference of the leader is to (get meetings finished) in two hours, and sometimes I didn’t feel like some members of the scrutiny committee performed very well.”

Asked whether he was referring to Liberal Democrat councillors, he said that “some asked probing questions” but that “some are reluctant to criticise the administration".

He insisted he would “definitely” remain on the panel, adding: “Even if it means we have to go over the notional two hours, I will still be asking questions.”

Cllr Juned believed there was “a lot more to” Cllr Crump’s decision than the two-hour issue. Asked what she thought the other reasons were, she replied: “I don’t know. That’s his choice and if that’s the decision he has come to then it will be accepted."

She said “there were some lengthy meetings” but “wouldn’t like to comment” on whether she believed they had gone on too long, declaring there had been “no conversation at all” between her and Cllr Crump on that.

Cllr Juned stated feedback from panel members, "not just from one party but across overview and scrutiny", suggested that there was room for improvement”.

When asked in what regard, she replied: “In making sure that the questions are sharply focused and that meetings are conducted in a timely manner, that they don’t go on for too long.”

However, she thanked Cllr Crump for his service and concluded: “It is not an easy role.”

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice