Theatre review - Underdog: The Other Other Brontë: It's not easy being an overlooked genius

Underdog: The Other Other Brontë

Underdog: The Other Other Brontëplaceholder image
Underdog: The Other Other Brontë | Criterion Theatre

The Criterion Theatre, Earlsdon, until 3 October.
Tickets:
https://criteriontheatre.co.uk

We know the Brontës. The remarkable sisters wrote some of the most significant works of fiction in the English canon. There’s Charlotte (Jane Eyre) and Emily (Wuthering Heights) and…who’s the other one? Oh yes, Anne, who wrote The Tenant of Wildfell Hall. Anne’s book was a wild success when it was first published, though it was later suppressed by sister Charlotte, who’s ruthless desire for recognition as a writer and as a woman writer in an exclusively male-dominated scene almost ruined the otherwise close relationship between the three women, stuck on a lonely moor in Yorkshire and dependent on each other for stimulation and support.

Anne-marie Greene’s direction gives Sarah Gordon’s 2024 already feisty modern-day revision of the Brontëmyth a quick-witted flair.  Much of this is due to the clever, knowing portrayal of Charlotte by Alice Scott. She is a pink-haired, elfin dominatrix of the family. Her determination to place herself at the top of the literary tree is expressed by frequent asides through the fourth wall, which draws us onto her side while at the same time slightly repelling us at the unfairness of her treatment of her sisters, Anne in particular. We forgive her, up to a point, partly because of her sparky charm and her knowing comments about the (still) patriarchal publishing game, but also because we buy into her idea that without her there would have been no Brontës. Even Emily, passionately, often angrily played by Nicole Cortese, is sidelined by her.

And what of poor Anne? Anne, the nice one, Anne the modest, self-effacing one who suspends her literary ambitions to become a governess, one of the lowest rungs of the Victorian social ladder, where she is bullied and humiliated by her employers and their nasty children. Somehow, she turns this unhappy experience into a scathing condemnation of abuse within marriage which was revolutionary in her day, and hits the jackpot with her book sales.

But in order to succeed the sisters had to pretend to be men, otherwise they would have been dismissed as mere ‘women writers.’ But this brings a conundrum. By pretending to be men they are, in a sense, beating the men at their own game and are somewhat protected by the mask, provided their true identities remain secret. Once they are revealed they are subject to the very condemnation they challenged in spite of, and because of, their success.

Sarah Gordon’s play doesn't delve too deeply into the books themselves; rather it is the Brontë myth that is explored and its status as a repudiation of patriarchy. Even Branwell Brontë (Connor Bailey), their wayward, drunken brother, who aspired to be a painter though he lacked the talent, is somehow portrayed as a victim of this London-based snobbery. Ironically by working together to create the image of the Bell brothers,  partly in order to protect him from full knowledge of himself, the sisters cannot help but buy into that snobbery.

Charlotte tries to rip the façade off the dominant ideology of the time by making herself into a literary superstar and using her fame to overturn the orthodoxy. It is self-conscious promotion with its roots in the past and its flower very much in the present. The cast, including an excellent ensemble, have great fun with it, playing with a punk / Gen Z theme. The performances are top-notch throughout, the three sisters well balanced in their characters, Charlotte as the apex of a triangle that could only function as a collective.

Underdog: The Other Other Brontë, is playing at The Criterion Theatre, Earlsdon, 'til 3 October. Tickets: https://criteriontheatre.co.uk

 

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice