Rugby Borough Council's leadership asks for 2026 elections to be cancelled
Rugby Borough Council’s Labour leadership is to ask for its 2026 elections to be cancelled despite staunch opposition from the Conservatives in Thursday’s spiky and hour-long debate.
The borough’s cabinet – the panel of six Labour councillors in charge of major service areas – unanimously voted to request that May’s ballots be scrapped in response to the national government's ask for their views.
The government makes the final decision but if it agrees, those meant to be up for election would carry on through to the abolition of the council as part of local government reorganisation, a process due to be completed by April 2028.
If the process to move towards unitary authorities – one level of local government instead of the two-tier county and borough system currently in place across Warwickshire – is completed on time, councillors would be elected to the new authority in 2027.


The current borough council, like the other districts and boroughs across Warwickshire, will continue to run services but increasingly get less of a say from those 2027 elections when a new ‘shadow’ authority comes into play.
That limited scope, the scale of the work involved with moving to unitary, the work required to set up a new town council for Rugby and the fact that many councils in similar positions have deferred elections in the past were the main reasons given at the Town Hall on Thursday night.
Cabinet members were invited to give their views and were clearly braced for a backlash amid arguments that scrapping elections would be undemocratic, particularly with Labour polling badly.
Councillor Maggie O’Rourke (Benn) kicked off by noting how much extra work was required in Rugby to establish a town council, claiming such plans had been “blocked” by former Conservative leader Seb Lowe when he was in office.
She also anticipated issues with staff capacity because of the imminent demise of the borough. “The best tend to go quite early when they don’t feel they have any control because of reorganisation,” she added.
Councillor Claire Edwards (Coton & Boughton) dared Tories who wanted elections to resign and trigger by-elections.
“I won’t stand in your way,” she said. “Please do take that in the manner it is sent in your direction.”
She added that the council already being in no overall control had led to a “co-operative working scenario” which was “actually making progress”, making the case to focus on getting “the very best deal for Rugby” ahead of the reorganisation.
“That has to be our focus rather than doing manifestos saying we are going to shut up shop,” said Cllr Edwards.
Councillor Alison Livesey (Coton & Boughton) leaned on her day job as a consultant on local government transformation.
“One of the reasons people like me do the job that I do is because no matter how willing council officers are, they cannot be in two places at once,” she said.
“Holding elections now is looking to the past and we really need to focus on the future.”
Councillor Louise Robinson (Admirals & Cawston) played down the political storm.
“We are not making the decision, the central government will,” she said.
“This hasn’t just gone out to Labour councils, it is not party political. My understanding is that if any council requests it and it meets the threshold, the minister has indicated the willingness to cancel elections.
“It feels transparent and open, it applies to all and doesn’t feel to me that it is biased in any particular way. It feels like a pragmatic decision."
The government asked the 63 councils in this position for a view, stating that came on the back of “several” expressing capacity concerns when it came to dovetailing work on elections and local government reorganisation.
Leader of the opposition Councillor Derek Poole (Con, Wolston & the Lawfords) queried whether Rugby had been among them with leader Councillor Michael Moran (Lab, Admirals & Cawston) confirming it hadn’t.
Cllr Poole also argued the smooth rollout of the administration's agenda was “not relevant to the decision” and that it was “down to the voters” to choose whether that continued, “not you”.
His deputy Councillor Simon Ward (Con, Wolston & the Lawfords) drilled down on the key reason quoted by government for cancellations – the capacity of councils.
“The report of the chief executive does not identify any such challenges,” he said.
Referencing the council’s report, which stated that elected officials “may wish to extend the case that the process of local government reorganisation will be extremely resource intensive”, Cllr Ward added: “This implies that the case is not self-evident and that it needs to be extended to meet the criteria set out by the government.”
Deputy leader of the Liberal Democrats Councillor Isabelle McKenzie (Rokeby & Overslade) said her group was due to meet on Monday (January 12) ahead of writing to express its view to the government but gave personal views and laid out the matters for consideration.
“I have never missed a vote in my life and am always going to start by wanting elections," she said.
“As Liberal Democrats we have nothing to fear from these elections and are targeting gains. From that point of view, cancellations would be personally disappointing for us as I have some great people waiting in the wings.”
However, she acknowledged that must be balanced with the risk of a “massive permanent democratic deficit” if a town council is not formed for Rugby.
“There is absolutely no guarantee that the shadow or new unitary would allow us to do so if we don’t get on with it now,” she added.
“The staff that need to do that work are in the elections team, that’s where the capability sits within the organisation. This work hasn’t really started yet.”
Cllr Moran took aim at the Tories in relation to the position on resources.
“The fact we are at this point now and you maybe don’t grasp how significant the challenge is facing this council, and other councils, is a concern,” he said.
He warned that 2026 could "run away with itself” and that the borough’s resources had been “stripped to the bone in the past 20 years”, making him “very aware of the limitations of what is possible”.
“Yes, absolutely, the elections could go ahead,” he said.
“The reality that dawns as 2026 progresses and we get further information on local government reorganisation, that challenge is going to come fast over the horizon.”